|
Advocates want roofs white to save energy
10/17/2004 12:00 AM CDT
Anton Caputo
San Antonio Express-News
The American dream soon could include a sparkling white roof to
match that quaint picket fence.
That's the vision of "cool roof" advocates who want to
persuade homeowners and businesses to replace their dark roofs with
pearly, energy-saving ones.
The difference, the advocates say, could save energy costs and
reverse the trend of large metropolitan areas turning into sweltering
hot pockets of smog.
A group of such advocates from around the state met in San Antonio
recently to discuss ways to combat the phenomenon called the "urban
heat island effect."
The theory is simple: Standard dark roofs absorb the sun's heat
— sometimes reaching temperatures as high as 190 degrees, according
to federal Environmental Protection Agency studies.
The increased heat, coupled with a similar effect from a city's
dark asphalt streets and parking lots, can heat an urban area up
to 10 degrees hotter than the surrounding countryside.
The result — besides sweaty residents — is increased air pollution
and higher power bills, as people rev up their air conditioners
to try to combat the heat. Every added degree can increase a city's
peak energy needs by as much as 2 percent, according to the EPA.
Several cities and states have instituted cool roof programs and
building codes to address the problem. Put simply, cool roofing
material, which is usually white, reflects the sun's rays and keeps
buildings cooler.
Some community leaders and residents would like to see a similar
movement gain momentum here, particularly with the area flirting
with federal sanctions for violating air pollution standards.
"We're already moving in that direction," said Linda
Stone, executive director of Metropolitan Partnership for Energy,
pointing to recent voluntary "green building" standards
and the city's new energy plan, both of which address cool roof
technology.
Among those leading the charge locally are people in the roofing
industry.
Contractor Roy Schauffele, who owns San Antonio's Division 7 Solutions,
has been touting the benefits of cool roofs for years and has installed
many around the state on large commercial and public buildings.
He describes the product used on flat roofs as a kind of "rubberized
paint" that is spread on the existing roof. It costs about
30 cents a square foot, but it extends the life of a roof and saves
up to 25 or 30 percent in energy, he said.
Given the potential savings, he thinks the movement will catch
on.
"I think as our cost of energy goes up, and I mean the total
cost — the air quality emissions, disposal of all this (roofing
debris) — we're going to go full circle in the construction industry,"
he said. "It's a sustainability issue."
CPS Energy put a cool roof on its North Side customer
service center and currently offers rebates to commercial buildings
that use the technology. However, it does not offer similar rebates
for homes.
That soon could change. The utility is investigating whether it
should include residential cool roof technology in its long-range
energy efficiency plan, expected to be complete by early next year.
Laura Compton, CPS supervisor of forecasting and pricing, said
one of the hurdles is sifting through the vast number of products
and technologies in the growing field. But she doesn't question
the potential benefit.
"My personal opinion is that it will really help cities like
San Antonio," she said. "I know for a fact that it is
hotter in the city of San Antonio than when you go 20 miles north.
We need to do something and use a little bit of logic and put white
roofs on."
White ceramic tile, which costs at least twice as much as common
roofing shingles, is a common cool roof material used on homes.
A study of six identical, side-by-side Habitat for Humanity homes
in Florida showed energy savings of 17 percent to 23 percent when
switching from black shingles to reflective white tiles or white
metal.
Bexar County energy manager Vince Fuentez said he also is investigating
the issue.
"If you can reduce energy costs, expand the life of the roof
and improve the quality of the roof and there is no net loss, it's
a win-win," he said.
There is little data on the heat island effect on San Antonio.
City arborist Debbie Reid said a 1990 study showed San Antonio temperatures
to be an average of 3 degrees higher than New Braunfels.
But she said that could have changed for the worse in the past
14 years with San Antonio's growth and the corresponding loss of
shade-providing trees.
As the impact becomes more obvious, Tommy Mangold Jr. of San Antonio's
Turner Roofing thinks the Alamo City will get used to the idea of
gleaming white roofs.
"It's something new and I don't know everything about it yet,
but what I do know is it's something that will be a reality soon,"
he said. "I would say in the next 10 years."
|